Why the U.S. Regulators Have Denied Grayscale Investments’ Bid to Convert the World’s Biggest Crypto Trust into an Exchange-Traded Fund

Posted on

Image Source: Unsplash

‍The crypto market is certainly a challenging one. The regulatory framework of most countries remains ambiguous, and regulators are concerned that many investors are chasing after new digital tokens without understanding the risks involved. As such, they have taken cautious action to ensure that investors are protected from potential risks. In September last year, Grayscale Investments – the company behind the world’s first Bitcoin trust – announced that it had filed for an SEC exemption so as to convert its trust into a standard exchange-traded fund (ETF). At present, the trust doesn’t trade on any stock exchange and is not available to retail investors. In this article, we’ll be taking a look at why U.S. regulators have denied Grayscale Investments’ bid to convert their trust into an ETF, what this means for other companies working on similar products and what it means for you as an investor in these types of investments.

What is a Grayscale Bitcoin Trust?

The Grayscale Bitcoin Trust is an investment fund that enables investors to buy Bitcoin, the first digital currency and the most well-known cryptocurrency, in a single investment, with minimal hassle. The Trust was set up in 2013 with the mission to make it easy for investors to get involved with cryptocurrencies, with minimal risk. The trust is not an investment fund in the traditional sense, as it does not actively manage the assets. Instead, it is a fund that holds a specific amount of Bitcoin as it becomes available on the market. This means that, unlike other funds, it does not have a set amount of money to invest and is not actively looking for new investment opportunities. The fund is operated by the Grayscale team, who manage the assets and keep track of the value of the assets, as well as execute the buy/sell orders when investors want to buy or sell their units in the fund.

Why the SEC Rejected Grayscale’s Bid to Convert Its Trust Into an ETF

The SEC has concerns over the liquidity of Bitcoin and its potential for price manipulation. In this, they also note the growing influence of retail investors in the crypto sector – many of whom don’t understand the complex nature of the sector and are particularly susceptible to manipulation. The SEC has also noted that, at present, the crypto trading sector is not robust enough to support a large-scale investment fund that could have wide-reaching consequences for the sector. Currently, the crypto trading sector relies on decentralized exchanges rather than centralized exchanges that are required for standard ETF trading. The SEC also has concerns that investors will not be able to withdraw their funds from the trust in an orderly fashion. Although some of these concerns have since dissipated with the growth of the crypto trading sector, the SEC has not yet been persuaded to change its stance.

How Does Grayscale’s Trust Work?

As we’ve mentioned, the Grayscale Bitcoin Trust is a fund that holds Bitcoins. However, it is not a fund that actively buys and sells those Bitcoins to make a profit – it simply holds onto the Bitcoin that it receives and lets it appreciate in value. For example, if you want to buy $10,000 worth of Bitcoin, you would buy 10,000 units of the trust. If the trust’s value goes up, then you will make a profit. However, if the trust’s value goes down, then you will lose money. For example, if the trust’s value drops to $9,000, you will lose $1,000. That being said, if the trust’s value goes up to $11,000, then you will make $2,000.

Why the SEC Is Concerned About Bitcoin ETFs

As we’ve mentioned, one of the main concerns of the SEC is the fact that the crypto trading sector currently relies on decentralized exchanges rather than centralized exchanges that are required for standard ETF trading. This is a big issue because decentralized exchanges are vulnerable to hacking. This is because they are operated by a large network of computers across the globe, making them more difficult to hack than a centralized exchange that is operated by a single computer system. The decentralized exchanges currently in use were also developed relatively recently, with many of them being created after the creation of the Bitcoin network in 2008. The SEC is concerned that a centralized exchange may not be able to withstand the high volume of trading that a Bitcoin ETF would bring, and that the ETF would be unable to protect investors from the consequences of hacking.

What This Means for Other Proposals Like Grayscale’s

As the SEC is denying Grayscale’s bid for a Bitcoin ETF, this also means that it is denying all other proposals for a Bitcoin ETF. This includes other companies that have also been trying to launch a Bitcoin ETF, such as VanEck and Bitwise. These companies have been trying to launch a Bitcoin ETF since last year, and they are also waiting to hear back from the SEC on their proposals. However, they have not received an indication of when they might hear the outcome of their proposals. That being said, it’s likely that the SEC will follow a similar path and reject their proposals.

What Does All of This Mean For You as an Investor?

As the SEC is denying all proposals for a Bitcoin ETF, this also means that you will be unable to buy Bitcoin with a single purchase through a fund. Instead, you will have to buy Bitcoin on a decentralized exchange, such as Coinbase or Binance. You will also be unable to sell your Bitcoin back into fiat currency through an ETF fund. Instead, you will have to sell your Bitcoin back into fiat currency on a decentralized exchange. Due to the fact that these exchanges are decentralized, there is currently no easy way to sell large amounts of Bitcoin back into fiat currency. This will make it more difficult for retail investors to buy and sell Bitcoin, as they will be required to use more advanced tools. Moreover, because there is no ETF that holds Bitcoin, there is no way to track the value of your investment in fiat currency. This means that it will be difficult to determine whether your investment is growing or shrinking. For example, if you buy $10,000 worth of Bitcoin and the value of Bitcoin is $10,000, then your investment is exactly where it started. However, if the value of Bitcoin goes up to $20,000, then you will have doubled your investment. If the value of Bitcoin goes down to $5,000, then you will have lost your entire investment.